The Argos laptop case: when does your right to return an online purchase end?
The Court of Appeal has ruled that a customer who switched on a £379 laptop bought online and set up Windows 11 did not lose his right to cancel. The decision matters for millions of online shoppers.
The case
Dr Ebenezer Adodo ordered a £379 laptop online from Argos. After switching it on and activating the pre-installed Windows 11, he tried to return it, but Argos refused, saying a 'digital seal' on the software had been broken. The county court sided with Argos.
What the court said
On 13 November the Court of Appeal unanimously ruled in Dr Adodo's favour. It said the sealed-software exception in the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013 must be read narrowly, and that consumers may switch a computer on to test it. Argos was ordered to repay the £379 with interest. Dr Adodo represented himself throughout.
Your basic online shopping rights
For purchases made online, by phone or by catalogue, you usually have 14 days after delivery to cancel without giving a reason. The seller must refund you within 14 days of getting the item back or receiving proof you've returned it.
Sellers have rights too
The ruling isn't a licence for unlimited use. If you handle an item more than you could in a shop, the seller can deduct an amount for loss of value — but it has to prove that loss. Argos did not try to do so in this case. This article is general information, not financial or legal advice.
This article is general information, not legal or financial advice. Always check the latest rules on GOV.UK or with a regulated professional.
